Is the produce squeeze worth it?

The Fresh Produce Consortium has gone public days before Friday’s UK–EU summit, and the pressure on the Prime Minister is plain. The question for the trade is whether the campaign is justified or just noise.
The case for the squeeze
The FPC’s headline claim is a big one: more than £300 million a year in added cost, nearly £6 million every week, on around four million tonnes of non-EU fresh produce destined solely for UK shoppers. If that figure holds, it is hard to wave away.
The supporting evidence is also hard to wave away. The FPC says the current UK regime already delivers 99.5% compliance across some 120,000 consignments a year, which raises the obvious question of what problem new checks would solve. Its argument that EU produce already enters Great Britain without plant health checks, and that goods imported solely for UK consumption cannot be re-exported to the EU, makes its exemption ask look modest rather than radical.
The FPC also leans on official material. A Defra survey found SMEs want less paperwork (79%), lower trading costs (78%) and fewer border delays (71%). A House of Lords committee reported that dynamic alignment could cause difficulties in wider trade relations, including with CPTPP and the UK’s deals with Australia and New Zealand.
The case for caution
Still, a trade body’s campaign is advocacy, and the limits are worth stating plainly.
The £300 million figure is the FPC’s own analysis, and the release does not show the workings. The FPC also says industry has been told almost nothing about what will change, which cuts both ways. If the detail is unpublished, nobody outside government can fully test the FPC’s description of the deal “as drafted”.
A question of balance
On balance, the squeeze looks worth it, mainly because of the asks themselves. Publishing what will change at the non-EU border, and proving the border is ready before any change takes effect, are hard to argue against whatever the summit delivers. Those two asks stand even if the £300 million figure is later challenged.
The exemption is the bigger bet, and it depends on numbers the sector has yet to see tested. For now, the FPC has made a credible case for transparency. Whether it has made the case for exemption will become clearer after Friday.
- Rodney Jack, editor, Food & Drink Technology. Keep in touch via email: [email protected] X: @foodanddrinktec or LinkedIn: Food & Drink Technology magazine.

